Natural Gas vs Propane Generators

When it comes to choosing the right generator for your home, business, or outdoor activities, two of the most popular fuel options are natural gas and propane. Both offer reliable power sources, but they come with distinct advantages and drawbacks that can make one more suitable than the other, depending on your specific needs. In this guide, we will compare natural gas and propane generators to help you make an informed decision. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of which generator type might be the best fit for your power needs.

What Are Natural Gas and Propane Generators?

Generators play a crucial role in providing backup power, whether it’s for residential, commercial, or industrial purposes. Among the various types of generators, natural gas and propane generators are two of the most popular options. These generators work in similar ways but differ primarily in the type of fuel they use.

Natural Gas Generators

Natural gas generators run on natural gas, which is supplied through pipelines. This makes them a convenient and often cost-effective option for those who live in areas with stable access to a natural gas supply. The fuel is delivered directly to the generator via a gas line, ensuring a continuous and reliable source of energy as long as the supply remains uninterrupted.

The primary advantage of natural gas generators is their constant fuel supply, which makes them ideal for long-term use, particularly in residential or commercial applications where regular power outages may occur. They tend to have a longer runtime compared to portable generators, especially since there’s no need for regular refueling.

However, natural gas generators do have some limitations. Since they rely on an external fuel source, they may be less useful in off-grid situations or areas without a consistent natural gas infrastructure. In the event of a gas supply failure, these generators will be rendered useless until the service is restored.

Propane Generators

Propane generators, on the other hand, use propane as their fuel source. Propane is a type of liquefied petroleum gas (LPG), which is stored in liquid form in portable tanks. This makes propane generators more versatile and suitable for a variety of applications, including residential, emergency backup, outdoor use, and even RVs.

One of the key advantages of propane generators is their portability. Since propane is stored in tanks, it’s easy to transport and refuel the generator, which makes them ideal for off-grid locations or for situations where the generator needs to be moved frequently. Additionally, propane has a long shelf life when stored properly, allowing users to keep fuel on hand for emergencies without worrying about fuel degradation over time.

However, propane generators do have their own set of challenges. Propane fuel tends to be more expensive than natural gas, especially over long periods of use. Propane tanks also need to be refilled regularly, which can be inconvenient if you don’t have easy access to a refill station. Furthermore, propane generators typically have a shorter runtime compared to natural gas generators, meaning they require more frequent refueling.

How Both Generators Work?

Both natural gas and propane generators operate using the same basic principle: they convert fuel into mechanical energy to generate electricity. Inside the engine, the fuel is burned, and the resulting heat creates power that is transferred to an alternator, which then produces electrical current. The difference lies in the type of fuel used in this process.

Natural gas generators rely on a constant gas supply delivered through pipelines, while propane generators store the fuel in liquid form within tanks that can be replaced or refilled when needed. Both systems have their advantages and limitations, depending on your location, power needs, and fuel availability.

Key Differences Between Natural Gas and Propane Generators

When deciding between a natural gas and a propane generator, it’s essential to understand the key differences that can impact your decision. These differences primarily relate to fuel source, energy efficiency, performance, and the overall convenience of each option.

1. Fuel Source and Availability

The most obvious difference between natural gas and propane generators is the fuel source. Natural gas is delivered to homes and businesses through underground pipelines, and it is continuously available as long as the supply remains uninterrupted. This makes natural gas generators ideal for those who have access to a reliable gas supply. They offer the advantage of not needing to worry about fuel storage or frequent refueling.

In contrast, propane is a liquefied gas stored in tanks. These tanks can be portable, allowing users to store and transport fuel as needed. Propane is often used in rural areas or off-grid locations where natural gas pipelines are unavailable. However, propane requires regular refilling, and you need to ensure you have a reliable fuel supplier nearby.

For those living in urban areas or regions with well-established gas pipelines, natural gas is the more convenient choice. Propane, however, is a better option for users who may need a portable power solution or live in remote areas without access to natural gas.

2. Energy Efficiency and Cost

Another significant difference between natural gas and propane generators lies in their energy efficiency and cost. Natural gas tends to be a more cost-effective fuel in the long term. Because it is typically delivered through pipelines, natural gas is less expensive to procure, especially for regular use. It also has a lower energy content per unit when compared to propane, meaning you need more natural gas to generate the same amount of power as propane.

Propane, on the other hand, is a more energy-dense fuel. This means that propane generators generally produce more power per gallon of fuel compared to natural gas generators. While propane is more expensive per gallon, it can be more efficient when considering the output. However, the higher cost of propane and the need for frequent refueling can make it more expensive for long-term use compared to natural gas.

When comparing the cost of operation, natural gas generally wins for daily or continuous use, especially if you have a reliable supply. Propane is more economical for short-term or backup power needs where fuel consumption is lower, or the generator is used intermittently.

3. Generator Performance and Power Output

Natural gas generators and propane generators generally perform similarly in terms of power output, but the specific type of fuel can affect the generator’s efficiency and power consistency. Since natural gas is delivered from a continuous pipeline, it can provide a steady and uninterrupted source of power, which makes it ideal for homes or businesses that require constant power during outages or as a backup.

Propane generators, while also capable of providing substantial power, tend to have slightly lower efficiency when compared to natural gas generators, primarily due to the nature of the fuel. However, propane engines are known to perform well in terms of power output per gallon of fuel. Propane generators may offer slightly less power on a long-term basis, but they often make up for it by being a practical and portable solution for emergency or off-grid use.

While both types of generators can provide significant power, natural gas generators are more reliable for long-term operation due to the consistent availability of the fuel source. Propane generators are better suited for intermittent use, especially when portability is needed.

4. Environmental Impact and Emissions

When it comes to environmental considerations, both natural gas and propane are considered cleaner alternatives to diesel or gasoline-powered generators. Both fuels produce fewer emissions than other fossil fuels, but there are some differences between the two.

Natural gas is considered the cleaner option in terms of carbon emissions, as it produces less CO2 when burned compared to propane and other fuels. It also emits fewer pollutants like nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter. This makes natural gas a more environmentally friendly choice for those who are concerned about their carbon footprint.

Propane, while still a cleaner fuel than gasoline or diesel, does produce slightly more carbon emissions than natural gas. However, it burns more cleanly than many other fuels and is a good choice for those looking for a more environmentally conscious option. Both fuels are better than traditional gasoline or diesel generators, but natural gas has the edge in terms of cleaner emissions.

5. Portability and Storage

One of the main advantages of propane generators is their portability. Since propane is stored in portable tanks, users can easily transport and store fuel, making propane generators an excellent choice for off-grid locations, RVs, or camping trips. These generators can be taken anywhere, and the flexibility of having portable fuel tanks allows for refueling on the go.

Natural gas generators, however, lack this level of portability. They require a direct connection to a natural gas supply via a pipeline, which restricts their use to areas where this infrastructure is available. While this makes natural gas generators convenient for permanent installations in areas with reliable gas service, it means they cannot be easily moved or used in remote locations.

For those looking for flexibility and mobility, propane generators are the better choice. But for users with access to a steady natural gas supply, natural gas generators provide convenience and a more stable, long-term fuel solution without worrying about storage or refueling.

6. Maintenance and Lifespan

Both natural gas and propane generators generally require less maintenance than gasoline or diesel generators, but there are some differences in terms of the fuel system. Natural gas generators tend to have fewer issues with fuel degradation since natural gas is delivered as a steady stream. Propane can degrade over time if it’s not stored properly, potentially affecting the performance of the generator if the fuel is old or improperly stored.

In terms of engine life, both types of generators can last for many years with regular maintenance. However, propane burns cleaner than natural gas, which can result in less carbon buildup inside the engine and may lead to slightly longer engine life for propane-powered generators. That being said, natural gas generators generally have a slightly lower overall maintenance cost since they don’t require fuel tank refills and are often more straightforward to maintain with fewer fuel-related components.

Pros and Cons of Natural Gas Generators

Natural gas generators are a popular choice for both residential and commercial applications due to their consistent power supply and environmental benefits. Like any product, they come with their own set of advantages and disadvantages.

Pros of Natural Gas Generators

1. Reliable Fuel Supply

One of the biggest advantages of natural gas generators is their reliable fuel supply. When connected to a natural gas pipeline, these generators have a continuous flow of fuel, making them ideal for long-term use and for situations where consistent power is necessary. There’s no need to worry about running out of fuel, as long as the pipeline remains intact and the gas service is uninterrupted.

This constant fuel supply is especially useful in situations like extended power outages, where having a generator that can run continuously without the need for refueling can be a significant advantage. Additionally, natural gas is generally cheaper than other fuel options, which makes it an economical choice over time.

2. Lower Operating Costs

Natural gas generators are more affordable to run compared to other fuel-powered generators, such as those that run on diesel or propane. Natural gas is often less expensive than both propane and gasoline, which can lead to significant cost savings, especially for long-term use. For those who require a backup generator for their home or business, using natural gas can help keep operating costs down.

Over the course of several years, natural gas will likely cost you less per kilowatt-hour of electricity generated compared to other fuels. This makes natural gas generators an appealing choice for people looking for a long-term solution without high operational costs.

3. Cleaner Emissions

Natural gas is known for being a cleaner fuel compared to diesel, gasoline, or even propane. When burned, it produces lower levels of harmful emissions, such as carbon dioxide (CO2), sulfur dioxide (SO2), and nitrogen oxides (NOx). This makes natural gas generators a more environmentally friendly option, especially in comparison to older, traditional gasoline or diesel-powered generators that emit much more pollution.

For individuals or businesses that are concerned about their environmental impact, natural gas generators provide a solution that can reduce their carbon footprint and contribute to cleaner air quality.

4. Low Maintenance Requirements

Natural gas generators are typically easier to maintain than their diesel or propane counterparts. Since natural gas burns more cleanly than other fuels, it leads to less carbon buildup inside the engine, which reduces the need for frequent maintenance and repairs. The absence of fuel degradation also means there is less concern about issues such as fuel clogging or contamination that can affect performance in other types of generators.

Natural gas generators often require fewer maintenance intervals and are generally more durable in the long run. This can be a significant benefit for those looking for a generator with lower overall maintenance needs.

5. Quiet Operation

Compared to diesel or gasoline-powered generators, natural gas generators are typically quieter during operation. This makes them a good choice for residential areas or places where noise could be a concern. The quieter operation can make using a natural gas generator less disruptive, especially if you need it to run for long periods.

The noise level difference can be particularly important for individuals who live in close proximity to neighbors or have noise-sensitive environments like offices, schools, or hospitals. A natural gas generator’s quiet operation helps ensure that power generation does not interfere with daily activities.

Cons of Natural Gas Generators

1. Dependence on Gas Supply Infrastructure

The biggest drawback of a natural gas generator is its reliance on a continuous gas supply. Since these generators are connected to a natural gas pipeline, they are only functional as long as the pipeline remains intact and operational. If there’s a disruption in the gas supply—due to a natural disaster, a pipeline failure, or maintenance issues—the generator will not be able to function.

This makes natural gas generators less ideal for remote locations or areas where natural gas infrastructure is not available. In these cases, users may need to look into alternative power sources, such as propane or diesel generators, that don’t depend on an external pipeline.

2. Limited Portability

Natural gas generators lack the portability that other generators, like propane or gasoline-powered units, offer. Since they rely on a fixed connection to a gas line, natural gas generators are best suited for stationary use. This means they cannot be easily relocated, making them unsuitable for mobile applications like RVs, construction sites, or camping.

For those who require a portable generator that can be easily moved from one location to another, a natural gas generator would not be the best option. Propane or gasoline generators are more versatile in this regard, offering greater flexibility for various uses.

3. Installation Costs and Complexity

While natural gas generators are generally more affordable to operate, their initial installation costs can be higher compared to portable propane or gasoline generators. Installing a natural gas generator typically requires connecting the unit to the local natural gas pipeline, which can involve significant upfront costs, especially if you need to run new gas lines to the generator’s location.

Additionally, the installation process for natural gas generators is more complex than for smaller, standalone units, which may require professional installation and permits. This can add to the total cost and make the process more time-consuming.

4. Vulnerability to Supply Interruptions

Though rare, natural gas generators are vulnerable to supply interruptions. Events like natural disasters, extreme weather, or even accidents can damage pipelines or disrupt gas delivery. In these cases, even if you have a natural gas generator, it will be rendered useless if the gas supply is cut off.

This issue is less of a concern with propane or gasoline generators, which are not dependent on a continuous supply of fuel. While interruptions to fuel delivery can still occur, they are generally less common and less impactful than disruptions to the gas supply for natural gas generators.

5. Limited Use in Off-Grid Locations

If you live in a remote area or an off-grid location without access to a natural gas supply, a natural gas generator may not be an option. Natural gas generators are only viable where there is an established gas infrastructure, so their use is largely limited to urban or suburban environments that are connected to natural gas pipelines.

In rural or off-grid areas, where gas pipelines may not be available, propane or diesel generators are often a more practical choice. These generators can operate independently of a centralized fuel supply and are more versatile for various applications.

Pros and Cons of Propane Generators

Propane generators offer unique advantages that make them an excellent choice for a variety of situations. They are versatile, portable, and relatively easy to use. However, like all power sources, they come with their own set of drawbacks.

Pros of Propane Generators

1. Portability and Flexibility

One of the primary benefits of propane generators is their portability. Since propane is stored in portable tanks, these generators are easy to transport and can be used virtually anywhere. Whether you need backup power at home, for an outdoor event, or during a camping trip, propane generators offer the flexibility to bring power to places where it might otherwise be unavailable.

The ease of transportation and the ability to use them in remote locations makes propane generators ideal for off-grid applications, such as cabins, RVs, or construction sites. With propane, you don’t need to worry about permanent infrastructure, as you can store and transport fuel as needed.

2. Long Shelf Life of Fuel

Unlike gasoline, propane has an almost indefinite shelf life when stored properly. It doesn’t degrade over time, which means you can keep propane tanks on hand for extended periods without worrying about the fuel becoming ineffective or unsafe to use. This is especially advantageous in emergency situations where you may not be able to refill your tank immediately.

For homeowners or businesses looking to keep a reliable backup power source, propane offers peace of mind knowing the fuel won’t go bad or require frequent replacement. In contrast, gasoline can go stale or evaporate, and diesel fuel can deteriorate, making propane a more reliable choice for long-term storage.

3. Cleaner Emissions

Although propane is still a fossil fuel, it burns much cleaner than gasoline or diesel. When burned, propane produces fewer carbon emissions, less carbon monoxide, and lower levels of particulate matter. This makes propane generators a more environmentally friendly option compared to their gasoline or diesel counterparts.

For those conscious about reducing their environmental footprint, propane generators provide an eco-conscious alternative while still offering the power needed during outages or off-grid situations. This is one of the reasons propane is commonly used for residential backup power, outdoor use, and emergency situations.

4. Less Maintenance

Propane is a cleaner-burning fuel compared to gasoline and diesel, which means it results in less wear and tear on the engine of the generator. When you use propane, the engine is less likely to accumulate carbon and oil deposits, leading to fewer maintenance requirements. This can result in a longer lifespan for the generator, reducing the need for costly repairs and extending the life of the unit.

Additionally, propane doesn’t go bad or cause issues like gasoline or diesel, which can leave residue in the engine. This contributes to less frequent maintenance and a smoother operation over time.

5. Safety Features

Propane is generally considered a safe fuel to handle, especially compared to gasoline. It has a high ignition point, which makes it less likely to catch fire than gasoline. Propane is also stored in tanks that are designed to handle high pressure, with built-in safety features like automatic shut-off valves and pressure relief valves to prevent accidents.

While proper care should still be taken when handling propane tanks, the safety features built into propane generators and tanks make them a reliable and secure option for homeowners and businesses alike.

Cons of Propane Generators

1. Higher Operating Costs

While propane is an efficient fuel, it is generally more expensive than natural gas and sometimes even more expensive than gasoline or diesel in certain markets. For long-term, consistent use, propane can become more costly than other fuel options. This is especially true if you are running a generator frequently or for extended periods.

For individuals or businesses looking for a cost-effective solution, propane may not be the most economical choice for long-term use. Although it offers many advantages, the price of propane can significantly impact the overall operating cost of the generator over time.

2. Limited Fuel Storage

Although propane can be stored for long periods, it still requires physical storage in tanks. The need for storage can become a limitation, especially if you require large quantities of fuel. Propane tanks, while portable, can take up considerable space, and large tanks may not be easy to transport, depending on your setup.

Additionally, you need to have a consistent supply of propane and may need to refill your tanks periodically. Depending on the location, propane refueling stations might not always be easily accessible, especially in remote areas. This could cause inconvenience or interruptions in power if you run out of fuel without a nearby refueling option.

3. Shorter Runtime

One downside of propane generators is their runtime. Propane has a lower energy content per gallon compared to natural gas and diesel. As a result, propane generators generally offer a shorter runtime before the fuel tank needs to be refilled. This is an important consideration if you need a generator for extended power outages or long-term use.

For example, while a natural gas generator can run indefinitely as long as there is a gas supply, propane generators will need to be refueled more frequently, especially during extended use. This can be an inconvenience if you’re relying on the generator for several days or weeks.

4. Requires Regular Refueling

Unlike natural gas generators, which are typically connected to a constant fuel source via pipelines, propane generators require you to manage your own fuel supply. You need to ensure that you have enough propane available to keep the generator running, which can be a hassle during extended outages or if you’re using the generator frequently.

Refueling propane generators also requires access to propane refilling stations, which may not always be convenient or available, especially in rural or remote locations. If you’re relying on a propane generator for emergency backup power, it’s important to have extra fuel on hand to avoid any downtime.

5. Storage and Handling Costs

While propane itself has a long shelf life, storing large amounts of propane can require significant space and investment in tanks. If you need to store multiple tanks of propane for emergency use, you’ll need to account for the cost of the tanks and the logistics of storage.

Additionally, handling propane requires following safety guidelines to prevent leaks or accidents. For those new to propane, understanding how to safely store and transport propane can add an extra layer of responsibility and cost.

Enjoyed this guide of Natural Gas vs Propane Generators? Then be sured to check out our other generator reviews.

• Best 2000 Watt Inverter Generator
• Best Tri-Fuel Generator
• Best 13000-Watt Generator
• Best 15000-Watt Generator
• Champion 2500 vs Honda EU2200i
• DuroMax XP13000EH vs XP13000HX
• Best 4000-Watt Inverter Generator